The Mafia collection has at all times been an outlier within the open-world motion style. Whereas the 2002 authentic may have simply been written off as one other Grand Theft Auto clone, Mafia and subsequent titles within the franchise carved a distinct segment for themselves by being narrative-driven experiences constructed round a particular time and place. Empire Bay from Mafia 1 and a couple of is an amalgamation of Chicago and New York created to seize the sensation of Thirties and 50s gangster tradition, whereas New Bordeaux from Mafia 3 tried to depict the Vietnam-era within the south. Mafia: The Outdated Nation efficiently continues this pattern with its depiction of Sicily within the early 1900s, however is finally held again by its shallow mechanics and dated design.
Mafia: The Outdated Nation follows Enzo Favara as he falls in with the Torrisi Crime Household. After fleeing the sulfur mines, Enzo is saved by Don Torrisi, a soft-spoken and enigmatic mob boss that seems like one other very well-known soft-spoken crime lord. Torrisi sees potential in Enzo and places him to work at his winery the place he meets Luca, a mentor-like determine to Enzo; Cesare, Don Torrisi’s hot-headed nephew; and Isabella, the Don’s daughter with whom Enzo has an immediate connection. All through the course of the 12-hour story, Enzo sinks deeper and deeper into the prison underworld. It’s a reasonably predictable mobster story that’s elevated by robust characters, nice performances, and considerate writing.
That mentioned, Mafia: The Outdated Nation’s solid doesn’t make the most effective first impression. Enzo could be very quiet and standoffish within the early hours; Don Torissi, at instances, sounds a little bit an excessive amount of like Michael Corleone; and Luca–despite being one in all my favourite characters by the end–comes throughout as simply one other rank-and-file mobster. Happily, after the primary couple of chapters, their personalities begin to come via extra strongly. That is very true for Luca, who helps information Enzo via his new life throughout the Torrisi household. In the meantime, Cesare develops past a easy hothead as he struggles to stay as much as his uncle’s lofty expectations. The one exception to the gradual burn of character personalities is Tino, Don Torrisi consigliere. Portrayed by Anthony Skordi, Tino makes a chilling impression out of the gate and regularly steals no matter scene he’s in.
Whereas I loved the characters, the story itself has been performed many instances earlier than, even inside this collection. A younger man falls in with the mafia. His new life is thrilling, however the cracks start to indicate. Individuals begin to die, and the protagonist should determine the place his loyalties lie. Completely different names fill the blanks, however the blanks are the identical. Whereas I had many points with Mafia 3, I appreciated the dangers it took with its story. Mafia: The Outdated Nation, by comparability, feels very secure. For those who’ve seen a gangster movie, don’t count on to be shocked by its twists and turns.
The place Mafia: The Outdated Nation excels is in its setting. The Sicilian countryside and the fictional city of San Celeste are breathtaking. The structure, outfits, automobiles, weapons, and all the things in between are superbly rendered and really feel genuine to the period. Hangar 13 is aware of this, too, as a result of most missions have a piece or two that require you to slowly stroll via intricately crafted units and lavishly detailed interiors. It will undoubtedly get on some individuals’s nerves, however given the artistry behind Mafia: The Outdated Nation, I didn’t thoughts these sections. Hangar 13 makes use of these moments as a chance for the environmental storytelling and world-building that the Mafia collection is understood for. San Celeste, and the way it adjustments all through the sport, is a superb instance of this. The city is steeped in historical past and tradition, and it may be seen on each road nook. Throughout occasions and festivals, components of town are reworked into crowded marketplaces and bustling festivals. It provides Mafia: The Outdated Nation a robust sense of place.
Hangar 13 brilliantly ties the narrative into its setting by referencing real-world occasions and capturing the sentiment of the period. The sport doesn’t start in a sulfur mine by mere coincidence. Within the early 1900s, sulfur was a significant export for Sicily, and the mines had been infamous for his or her lethal working circumstances and excessive exploitation of staff. Some mines had been even linked to the Sicilian Mafia because of the decentralized authorities of the time. The sulfur mines are only one instance of how Mafia makes use of actual historical past to tell its story and characters. There’s even one second close to the tip of the sport that makes use of the nation’s geographical options and actual pure phenomena to dramatic impact.
However regardless of its obvious element, Mafia: The Outdated Nation feels extra like an elaborate museum exhibit than a online game. There’s little or no to work together with outdoors of your present most important goal, and if you happen to discover a method to push the boundaries of the world, the sport not often responds appropriately. That is considerably comprehensible given Mafia: The Outdated Nation’s linear mission construction. As an alternative of the seamless open world you would possibly count on from a Grand Theft Auto–or even from 2016’s Mafia 3–The Outdated Nation’s mission design echoes Mafia 1 and a couple of, so when one chapter ends, a brand new one begins, leaving little room for exploration in between. Broadly talking, that is the correct transfer and permits Hangar 13 to place its story entrance and heart. Nonetheless, if you happen to discover time to enterprise from the important path (or load up the sport’s Exploration mode), you’ll discover a disappointingly one-dimensional world. There isn’t a regulation enforcement, NPCs usually don’t react to your actions irrespective of how chaotic, and weapon utilization is restricted inside most main areas. The Mafia video games aren’t recognized for his or her deep interactivity and reactivity, and I wasn’t anticipating The Outdated Nation to interrupt new floor right here, however this nonetheless appears like a step down from earlier entries.
This rigidity extends to the gameplay. Mafia: The Outdated Nation depends on a handful of dated instant-fail stealth segments with poor checkpointing to interrupt up the tempo of driving, taking pictures, and cutscenes in a typical mission. These vary from inconvenient to irritating. One particularly sees Enzo sneaking right into a authorities facility to crack a secure. It’s a enjoyable premise, however one slip-up places you again outdoors to begin over, no matter how deep you make it into the constructing. At first, I gave these instant-fail stealth missions the good thing about the doubt, since there are apparent story the explanation why Enzo wouldn’t wish to be noticed. Nonetheless, more often than not, a gunfight erupts anyway, making all that trial and error really feel trivial.
Fight is an enchancment over 2020’s Mafia: Definitive Version, however this nonetheless appears like a generic cover-based shooter. You might have two weapons, grenades, and–if you’ve one equipped–a throwing knife. Aiming and motion are a bit stiff on a controller and the focusing on reticule could be fairly imprecise, which may feasibly be defined away by unwieldy early-Twentieth century firearms. Lots of the satisfaction in gunplay comes from explosive sound design and weapon suggestions. The firearms in The Outdated Nation really feel lethal, knocking enemies again and annihilating the muddle scattered across the battlefield. It helps that the enemy AI at the usual issue is aggressive and infrequently intelligent. Enemies would usually flank and push a bonus when there was a gap, requiring me to react on the fly. Fight by no means turned troublesome, but it surely required simply sufficient fast pondering and ammo administration to maintain issues attention-grabbing.
Important encounters finish in a knife battle. Mechanically, these fights are simplistic however do an honest job at breaking apart the tempo of ducking into cowl for gunfights. Throughout these duels, Enzo can dodge, counter, slash, thrust, and break an enemy’s guard. There’s simply sufficient depth to maintain these brawls participating, however they by no means develop past a mildly entertaining diversion. Thematically, although, these fights rapidly develop into ridiculous. Each necessary antagonist is able to toss their gun apart and sq. up with Enzo, even when they’re giving up a transparent benefit. Early on, Enzo pulls a knife on his boss on the mines, and quite than intervening, everybody simply stands round and watches the violence. Certain, to an extent, that is normal fare for a online game. Nonetheless, given how grounded Mafia: The Outdated Nation’s story is, it is odd that Hangar 13 falls again on this gimmick so usually. In lots of circumstances, I’d have simply most well-liked a cutscene or a easy shootout.
Mafia: The Outdated Nation is at its finest when issues decelerate, letting you absorb all of the sights and sounds of Sicily. Like earlier Mafia video games, it nails the appear and feel of its real-world counterpart by investing closely within the particulars. Sadly, generic gameplay and dated mission design maintain Mafia: The Outdated Nation again, making it really feel like a relic of the early 2010s.