PORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti — Not one suspect imprisoned in Haiti has confronted trial after being charged within the killing of President Jovenel Moïse, who was gunned down at his home within the nation’s capital practically 4 years in the past.
Gang violence, death threats and a crumbling judicial system have stalled an ongoing investigation outlined by outbursts and tense exchanges between suspects and judges.
“You failed in your mission. And you aren’t ashamed to declare your self harmless,” Choose Claude Jean mentioned in a booming voice as he stood and confronted a Haitian policeman answerable for defending the president, who was shot 12 instances in Port-au-Prince on July 7, 2021.
Jean is considered one of six Haitian judges investigating whether or not there may be sufficient proof to warrant a trial for the 20 suspects held within the troubled Caribbean nation. Authorities mentioned a number of the suspects envisioned a coup, not an assassination, resulting in profitable contracts underneath a brand new administration.
The suspects embrace 17 former troopers from Colombia and three Haitian officers: an ex-mayor, a former policeman and a former Haiti Ministry of Justice worker who labored on an anti-corruption unit. Lacking are a number of key Haitian suspects who escaped final yr after a strong gang federation raided Haiti’s two biggest prisons, together with Dimitri Hérard, ex-head of safety at Haiti’s Nationwide Palace.
Three different suspects, all Colombians, have been killed hours after Moïse was slain, whereas a key suspect within the case, Haitian Superior Court docket Choose Windelle Coq Thélot, died in January whereas nonetheless a fugitive.
The investigation was repeatedly halted by the resignation of judges who feared for his or her lives. Protection attorneys then appealed after the court docket dominated there was adequate proof for trial. Jean and 5 different judges are actually tasked with restarting the inquiry. However figuring out complicity amongst 51 suspects is just one of quite a few challenges.
Final yr, powerful gangs seized management of the downtown Port-au-Prince courthouse the place the judges have been interrogating suspects. The hearings have been suspended till the federal government rented a house in Pacot, a neighborhood as soon as thought-about secure sufficient for the French embassy. However gangs controlling 85% of Haiti’s capital not too long ago attacked and compelled the federal government to maneuver once more.
The hearings restarted in Could, this time in a personal dwelling in Pétion-Ville, a neighborhood attempting to defend itself from gangs seeking full control of Port-au-Prince.
As a fan swirled lazily within the background, Choose Phemond Damicy grilled Ronald Guerrier in late Could.
One in every of a number of law enforcement officials tasked with defending the president, Guerrier insisted he by no means entered Moïse’s dwelling and couldn’t struggle the intruders as a result of he was dazed by a stun grenade.
“The attackers have been dressed all in black. They wore balaclavas and blinded us with their flashlights. I couldn’t establish anybody,” Guerrier testified, including they used a megaphone to say they have been U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration brokers. “The attackers operated as in the event that they have been coming into their very own dwelling. It appeared they knew the place completely.”
Damicy requested in the event that they shot at drones that Guerrier mentioned have been buzzing above the president’s dwelling.
“The attackers coated the whole space with their fireplace,” Guerrier replied. “There was nothing we might do.”
Damicy grew exasperated. “In no way ought to an enemy cross you with impunity to commit his crime,” he mentioned. “In your home, I might fireplace on the enemy. I might even die, if obligatory.”
Contained in the investigation’s closely guarded, stone-and-concrete headquarters in a leafy residential neighborhood, raised voices have dominated tense interrogations.
One choose stood and thundered a query a couple of gun: “On the day of the demise of President Jovenel Moïse, have been you in possession of a Galil?”
In one other outburst in March, a choose repeatedly pressed Joseph Badio, the previous Ministry of Justice official who spent two years on the run, about his name to former Prime Minister Ariel Henry after the assassination. On the time, Henry had solely been nominated as prime minister by Moïse.
“You’ll be able to say no matter you need along with your mouth,” Badio instructed the choose, who ordered him to take a seat as he rose whereas talking. “There isn’t a prohibition for me to speak with anybody I would like.”
The strain has carried over into interrogations of the Colombian suspects, who preserve they have been employed by a Miami-based security firm to supply safety for energy and water therapy crops and diplomatic officers, in addition to practice Haitian police and troopers.
The Colombians have denied involvement, whereas their lawyer, Nathalie Delisca, mentioned there was no presumption of innocence in the course of the interrogations.
“The therapy inflicted on the detainees was inhumane,” she mentioned, alleging mistreatment by authorities after their arrest.
The previous troopers mentioned they have been crushed, threatened with demise, pressured to signal paperwork in a language they don’t perceive and barred from speaking with their legal professionals and households for lengthy stretches.
“I’ve been subjected to degrading therapy. I’ve been subjected to bodily and psychological torture,” Jheyner Alberto Carmona Flores mentioned throughout a latest listening to.
He spoke Spanish in a transparent and loud voice, typically correcting an interpreter translating his testimony into French.
“I’ve no involvement as a result of I don’t know when or the place the president was assassinated,” Carmona Flores mentioned, claiming he was summoned to supply safety on the perimeter of Moïse’s home and didn’t know the president had been fatally shot.
Whereas the case in Haiti has stalled, the U.S. has charged 11 extradited suspects, with 5 already pleading responsible to conspiring to kill Moïse.
5 different suspects are awaiting trial, which is now scheduled for March 2026.
They embrace Anthony “Tony” Intriago, proprietor of Miami-based CTU Safety, and Haitian-People James Solages, a key suspect, and Christian Emmanuel Sanon, a pastor, physician and failed businessman who envisioned himself as Haiti’s new chief.
Moïse’s widow, Martine Moïse, is anticipated to testify within the U.S. case. She was injured within the assault and accused by a Haitian choose of complicity and prison affiliation, which her attorneys deny.
Court docket paperwork say the plan was to detain Jovenel Moïse and whisk him away, however modified after the suspects did not discover a aircraft or adequate weapons. A day earlier than Moïse died, Solages falsely instructed different suspects it was a CIA operation and the mission was to kill the president, the paperwork allege.
Bruner Ulysse, a lawyer and historical past professor in Haiti, lamented how the native investigation has highlighted what he known as “profound challenges” in Haiti’s judicial system.
“Whereas worldwide efforts have yielded some outcomes, the search for justice in Haiti stays elusive,” Ulysse mentioned. “Judges, prosecutors and legal professionals function underneath fixed risk.”
___
Coto reported from San Juan, Puerto Rico.