Why an explosive battle erupted over the UK’s new Chinese language embassy

The sheet of paper says “Wished Particular person” on the high. Beneath is a photograph of a younger lady, a headshot which may have been taken in a studio. She appears to be like instantly on the digicam, smiling together with her tooth displaying, and her darkish, shoulder-length hair is neatly brushed.

On the backside, in purple, are the phrases: “A reward of 1 million Hong Kong {dollars},” along with a UK cellphone quantity.

To earn the cash, about £95,000, there’s a easy instruction: “Present info on this wished individual and the associated crime or take her to Chinese language embassy”.

The lady from the photograph is standing in entrance of me. She shudders when she appears to be like on the constructing.

We’re exterior an imposing construction that was as soon as house to the Royal Mint and which China hopes it might become a brand new mega-embassy in London, changing the far smaller premises it has occupied since 1877.

The brand new premises, reverse the Tower of London, is already being patrolled by Chinese language safety guards. The constructing is ringed with CCTV cameras too.

“I’ve by no means been this shut,” admits Carmen Lau.

Carmen, who’s 30, fled Hong Kong in 2021 as pro-democracy activists within the territory have been being arrested.

She argues that the UK shouldn’t permit China’s “authoritarian regime” to have its new embassy in such a symbolic location. Considered one of her fears is that China, with such an enormous embassy, might harass political opponents and will even maintain them within the constructing.

There are additionally worries, amongst some dissidents, that its location – very close to London’s monetary district – could possibly be an espionage threat. Then there may be the opposition from residents who say it will pose a safety threat to them.

The plans had beforehand been rejected by the native council, however the determination now lies with the federal government – and senior ministers have signalled they’re in favour if minor changes are made to the plan.

The positioning is sprawling, at 20,000 sq. metres, and if it goes forward it will mark the largest embassy in Europe. However would it not additionally actually carry the risks that its opponents concern?

China purchased the outdated Royal Mint Court docket for £255m in 2018. The world has layer upon layer of historical past: throughout the highway is the Tower, elements of it have been constructed by William the Conqueror. For hundreds of years kings and queens lived there.

The plan itself entails a cultural centre and housing for 200 workers, however within the basement, behind safety doorways, there are additionally rooms with no recognized use on the plans.

“It is simple for me to think about what would occur if I used to be taken to the Chinese language embassy,” says Carmen.

In 2022, a Hong Kong pro-democracy protester was dragged into the grounds of the Chinese language consulate in Manchester and overwhelmed. British police close by stepped over the boundary to rescue him.

Again in 2019, mass protests had erupted in Hong Kong, triggered by the federal government’s try to herald a brand new legislation permitting for Hong Kong residents to be extradited to China.

China’s response included a legislation that pressured all elected officers in Hong Kong, together with Carmen who was then a district councillor, to take an oath of loyalty to China. Carmen resigned as a substitute.

She claims that journalists for Chinese language state-run media began following her. The Ta Kung Pao newspaper, which is managed by China’s central authorities in Beijing, ran a entrance web page story alleging she and her colleagues had held events of their council places of work.

“You realize the ways of the regime,” she says. “They have been following you, attempting to harass you. My mates and my colleagues have been being arrested.”

Carmen fled to London however believes that she has continued to be focused.

Hong Kong issued two arrest warrants for her alleging “incitement to secession and collusion with a overseas nation or with exterior components to hazard nationwide safety”.

The bounty letter despatched from Hong Kong to half a dozen of her neighbours adopted.

“The regime simply [tries] to get rid of any potential activists abroad,” she says.

Steve Tsang, a political scientist and historian who’s director of the SOAS China Institute, says he can see why individuals from Hong Kong, or sure different backgrounds, could also be uncomfortable with the brand new embassy.

He argues “the Chinese language authorities since 1949 doesn’t have a file of kidnapping individuals and holding them of their embassy compounds.”

However he says some embassy workers could be tasked with monitoring Chinese language college students and dissidents within the UK and so they’d additionally goal UK residents, comparable to scientists, enterprise individuals, and people with affect, to advance China’s pursuits.

The Chinese language embassy advised the BBC it “is dedicated to selling understanding and the friendship between the Chinese language and British peoples and the event of mutually helpful cooperation between the 2 nations. Constructing the new embassy would assist us higher carry out such tasks”.

There’s one other concern, held by some opponents, that the Royal Mint Court docket web site might permit China to infiltrate the UK’s monetary system by tapping into fibre optic cables carrying delicate information for corporations within the Metropolis of London.

The positioning as soon as housed Barclays Financial institution’s buying and selling ground, so it was wired instantly into the UK’s monetary infrastructure. Close by, a tunnel has, since 1985, carried fibre optic cables beneath the Thames serving lots of of Metropolis corporations.

And within the grounds of the Court docket, is a five-storey brick constructing – the Wapping Phone Alternate that serves the Metropolis of London.

In line with Prof Periklis Petropoulos, an optoelectronics researcher at Southampton College, direct entry to a working phone change might permit individuals to glean info.

This has all prompted warnings about potential espionage – together with from Conservative frontbencher Kevin Hollinrake, in addition to senior Republicans within the US.

An official with safety expertise in former US president Joe Biden’s administration advised me it is completely potential that cables could possibly be tapped with units that may seize passing info – and that this may be virtually unimaginable to detect.

“Something as much as half a mile from the embassy could be weak,” he says.

Nonetheless, he argues that China will not be inclined to do that as a result of it has different methods of hacking into methods.

Concerning these considerations, the Chinese language embassy stated: “Anti-China forces are utilizing safety dangers as an excuse to intrude with the British authorities’s consideration over this planning utility.

“This can be a despicable transfer that’s unpopular and won’t succeed.”

In the back of the Royal Mint Court docket is a row of Eighties-built flats. Mark Nygate has lived right here for greater than 20 years. He gestures throughout his low backyard wall. “Embassy workers will reside there and overlook us,” he says.

“We do not need [the embassy] there due to demonstrations, due to the safety dangers, due to our privateness.”

Opponents of the embassy – Hong Kongers, Tibetans, Uighurs, and opposition politicians – have already staged protests involving as much as 6,000 individuals.

Principally, although, he fears an assault on the embassy – that might hurt him and his neighbours.

However Tony Travers, a visiting professor within the LSE Division of Authorities, lives close to the present embassy and is not satisfied that these types of protests will materialise for the brand new neighbours, if the relocation goes forward.

“I am not conscious of any proof that there are common protests that block the highway exterior the present Chinese language embassy… self-evidently, there are a lot bigger protests exterior quite a lot of different nations’ embassies and excessive commissions.”

The Chinese language embassy in London says that the proposed growth would “tremendously enhance the encompassing surroundings and produce advantages to the area people and the district”.

China’s first planning utility to develop the positioning was rejected by Tower Hamlets council in 2022 over security and safety considerations – and fears protests and safety measures might harm tourism.

Moderately than amend the plan or attraction, China waited, then resubmitted an similar utility in August 2024, one month after Labour got here to energy.

On 23 August, Sir Keir Starmer phoned Chinese language President Xi Jinping for his or her first talks. Afterwards Sir Keir confirmed that Xi had raised the difficulty of the embassy.

Since then, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner has exercised her energy to take the matter out of the council’s fingers, after being urged to take action by International Secretary David Lammy.

That is within the context of an try by the federal government to have interaction with China after earlier Conservative Prime Minister Rishi Sunak declared in 2022 that the so-called “golden period” of UK-China relations have been over.

For his half, Prof Travers believes that politics is concerned in planning choices.

“The Secretary of State has to make the choice on the idea of the documentation in entrance of them and the legislation surrounding and affecting the difficulty,” he argues.

“However it will be naïve to think about that politics did not play a task.”

Lord Peter Ricketts, a former diplomat who chaired the UK’s Nationwide Safety Council, advising prime ministers on international threats, stresses that the nation’s relationship with China is complicated.

A Nationwide Safety Technique revealed in June laid out the conflicting priorities within the authorities’s strategy, highlighting its want to make use of the connection to spice up the UK economic system but in addition seemingly “continued rigidity” over human rights and cyber safety.

However is that duality of reaping the enterprise advantages whereas pushing on the human rights transgressions, even potential?

“It’s completely an adversary in some areas, which tries to steal our mental property, or suborn our residents,” says Lord Ricketts. “(However) it’s a business market, a vital one for us, and it is a participant within the massive international points like local weather and well being.

“We’ve got to have the ability to deal with China in all these classes on the identical time.”

The embassy determination, he says, cuts to the guts of this. “There are acute dilemmas, and there are selections to be made, whether or not to privilege the 30, 40 or 50-year relationship with China, which an embassy, I assume, would symbolise.

“Or whether or not to offer precedence to the short-term safety threats, that are little question actual as properly.”

The Conservative MP Sir Iain Duncan Smith is satisfied giving the go-ahead for the brand new embassy could be an enormous mistake. “They suppose that the one manner they will get progress is by kissing as much as China and getting them to take a position,” he tells me.

However for all of the considerations round safety, having one massive embassy might properly make it simpler to regulate what Chinese language officers are as much as within the UK, in keeping with Prof Tsang.

“Permitting the Chinese language to place their workers on one web site is preferable,” he argues, “as a result of they’re in the intervening time in all places in London, you possibly can’t truly regulate them.”

He isn’t satisfied that rejecting or approving the embassy will affect enterprise and commerce.

“The Chinese language are absolutely the final pragmatists. They aren’t going to abruptly say that no, we’re not promoting our greatest electrical autos to you any longer simply since you denied us the embassy,” he says.

However, equally, “they aren’t going to considerably improve Chinese language investments within the UK as a result of they’ve the brand new embassy compound.”

If Angela Rayner thinks that too, then her determination could properly come all the way down to how severely she takes the warnings that China might snoop on the UK’s banks.

If she rejects the embassy it might be as a result of she judges the hazard it poses to be very actual certainly.

Prime picture credit: Reuters, Richard Baker by way of Getty Pictures, SOPA Pictures by way of Getty Pictures and EPA -EFE/REX/Shutterstock

BBC InDepth is the house on the web site and app for the very best evaluation, with recent views that problem assumptions and deep reporting on the largest problems with the day. And we showcase thought-provoking content material from throughout BBC Sounds and iPlayer too. You possibly can ship us your suggestions on the InDepth part by clicking on the button under.