-
Dan Graziano
The Jacksonville Jaguars say they’ve a plan for hybrid rookie celebrity Travis Hunter, and it seems they intend to make use of him on each side of the ball. Hunter, who won the Heisman Trophy at Colorado final season for his work at large receiver and cornerback, has primarily practiced with the Jaguars’ offense to this point this offseason. However he is additionally getting in some practice work with the protection, and he will offensive and defensive conferences, as properly.
Given the worth the Jaguars paid to move up — principally two first-round picks and a second-round decide — and choose Hunter No. 2 in final month’s draft, it has been clear for some time that they see him as a participant who can contribute in a number of methods on a doubtlessly unprecedented stage. And if Hunter is the participant the Jaguars think about he may be for them, it could increase fascinating points in future years concerning how he will get paid.
The NFL’s collective bargaining settlement has particular guidelines governing issues like performance-based pay, contract incentives, franchise-tag designations and fifth-year choices. However how properly did the CBA’s guidelines anticipate a participant seeing a considerable variety of snaps on either side of the ball? What may this imply for Hunter’s future incomes potential, despite the fact that a drafted participant cannot negotiate a brand new deal till after his third NFL season and we do not know what the panorama will seem like three years from now?
We dug into the CBA’s language and referred to as some wage cap consultants across the league to debate Hunter’s distinctive state of affairs. Here is what we discovered.
Soar to extra on Hunter’s potential …
Performance-based pay
Fifth-year option, tag money
Contract incentives
Efficiency-based pay
Enjoying on each side of the ball would assist Hunter considerably within the NFL’s performance-based pay system (PBP), which is designed to enhance participant salaries by giving out bonuses within the offseason tied to enjoying time from the earlier season. Every crew will get a set pool of cash for performance-based pay bonuses (it was $14.128 million per crew this previous 12 months), and the cash is divvied up in keeping with a formulation that entails the participant’s wage, signing bonus proration, different bonuses and enjoying time.
The formulation is difficult, however CBA Article 28, Part 5(a) says every participant’s playtime proportion is decided by “including the participant’s complete performs on offense or protection, as acceptable, plus particular groups and (ii) dividing that quantity by the full performs of the participant on the crew’s roster with essentially the most mixed performs on offense, protection and particular groups for that Membership.”
So, to make use of a newsy example, San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy‘s 2024 compensation for PBP functions was $1,238,073. His mixed snaps on offense and particular groups (he did not play on particular groups, however that is how the formulation works) have been 81.3% of the full snaps performed by the 49ers participant with final season’s highest general snap depend, guard Dominick Puni. That resulted in a performance-based bonus of $857,842.49 for Purdy this offseason — the Sixteenth-highest quantity within the league. In distinction, 49ers linebacker Dre Greenlaw, whose compensation for PBP functions was $9,191,206 however performed solely 3% as many snaps as Puni, obtained a performance-based pay bonus of simply $4,284.28.
Now, what jumped out from the formulation was that “or” between the phrases “offense” and “protection.” We questioned if that meant it needed to be one or the opposite, however in consulting with varied NFL crew cap personnel and different cap consultants, we decided it doesn’t. For instance, Scott Matlock is a Los Angeles Chargers fullback who additionally performed on the defensive position final season. He obtained $645,902.08 in performance-based pay after making $1,263,153 in 2024 compensation. Operating his numbers via the formulation, he may solely have attained that determine by counting all of his 361 offensive snaps, 137 defensive snaps and 231 particular groups snaps.
So sure, any snaps Hunter performs on protection could be added to his offensive and particular groups snaps for functions of those calculations subsequent season (and in future years). Predicting simply how profitable that will probably be is tough, although, as a result of it is tied to how a lot everybody else on the crew performs and their respective salaries.
However let’s assume Hunter performs sufficient to be the Jaguars’ Dominick Puni — the participant with essentially the most general snaps of anybody on the Jacksonville roster — and mission subsequent 12 months’s PBP pool at round $16 million per crew (based mostly on annual will increase to that quantity in recent times). In that case, factoring in his $840,000 first-year wage and the proration of his $30,566,628 signing bonus, Hunter might be in line to pocket an additional $300,000 or $400,000 subsequent offseason.
For context, final 12 months’s No. 2 decide — Washington quarterback Jayden Daniels — performed in 84.8% of his crew’s mixed offensive and particular groups snaps and earned $177,324.77 in performance-based pay. And keep in mind, the Jaguars don’t have any purpose to restrict Hunter’s snaps to keep away from the next performance-based fee; the PBP pool is ready and equal for each crew, and each crew is required to spend all of it.
The fifth-year choice and franchise/transition tags
As with all first-round picks, Hunter’s contract will embrace a crew choice for a fifth season. That choice must be exercised by the primary week of Might following his third season. So in his case, the Jaguars must determine by Might 2028 whether or not to choose up his choice for the 2029 season.
The quantity of the choice is decided by play time and Professional Bowl choices in a participant’s first three years, and it varies by place. For this year’s group — 2022 first-round picks with choices for 2026 — the highest cornerback choice quantity was $20.187 million, whereas the highest large receiver quantity was $23.959 million. (The franchise tag numbers for these positions have been the identical as the highest fifth-year choice numbers this 12 months.)
We do not know for a proven fact that the hole between the cornerback quantity and the large receiver quantity would be the similar three years from now, but when Hunter have been going through the choice or the tag this 12 months, he’d actually a lot favor to be categorized as a large receiver than a cornerback. The factor is, he would not get to make that selection.
Article 10, Part 2 of the CBA expressly states {that a} franchise participant’s tender will probably be decided by “the place at which the Franchise participant participated in essentially the most performs throughout the prior League 12 months.” Article 7, Part 7 states that the participant’s fifth-year choice standing will probably be decided by the place at which he participated in essentially the most performs throughout his third league 12 months. So if Hunter have been to play, for instance, 400 snaps at cornerback and 399 at large receiver in 2027, his fifth-year choice could be for the cornerback wage. The identical factor goes if he had the identical break up within the last 12 months of his contract and the Jaguars selected to franchise him.
“In that case,” mentioned one cap skilled who works for an company, “they might do what the Ravens did with Judon.”
The instance in query is that of Matthew Judon, the sting rusher who was designated a franchise participant by the Baltimore Ravens in 2020. As a result of the 2019 Ravens performed a 3-4 defensive entrance as an alternative of a 4-3, their edge rushers have been technically exterior linebackers and never defensive ends. This mattered to Judon as a result of the franchise tag for linebackers at the moment was $14.808 million and the defensive finish tag was $18.808 million. (It is a flaw, after all, within the franchise tag system, which might be fairer if it grouped all such gamers right into a single “edge rusher” class, however we digress.)
The Ravens finally compromised with Judon and signed him to a one-year contract value $16.808 million — the halfway level between the 2 numbers. They did not have to do that, however it was a method of creating the participant glad and getting him to signal, and any comparable hypothetical future dispute with Hunter may theoretically be resolved the identical method by the Jaguars.
Contract incentives
If Hunter performs vital snaps on each side of the ball, he and his brokers may have some enjoyable attempting to construct incentive clauses into his second contract as soon as he is extension-eligible after the 2027 season. The CBA could be very particular about what sorts of incentives may be included in participant contracts (i.e., the form of crew and particular person achievements they are often based mostly on). Article 13, Part 6 of the CBA consists of the next passage:
“Any participant whose major place is on offense can’t have an incentive bonus that is determined by crew efficiency on protection (or particular groups), except such participant performed in 15% or extra of the Membership’s defensive (or particular groups) within the prior season (professional ranking participation within the occasion of video games missed as a consequence of damage). Any participant whose major place is on protection can’t have an incentive bonus that is determined by crew efficiency on offense (or particular groups), except such participant performed in 15% or extra of the Membership’s offensive (or particular groups) performs within the prior season (professional ranking participation within the occasion of video games missed as a consequence of damage).”
1:44
Travis Hunter able to take the NFL by storm with the Jaguars
Take a look at the explanations Travis Hunter is usually a celebrity within the NFL.
So, whereas the CBA would enable a participant contract to incorporate an incentive bonus tied to his crew ending, say, prime 10 within the league in fewest yards allowed on protection, an offensive participant couldn’t get such an incentive in his contract. Nonetheless, Hunter — assuming he performed 15% of the crew’s defensive performs along with his offensive contributions the season earlier than his extension — could be an exception.
As for particular person incentives, the CBA permits for bonuses to be tied to any number of achievements — dashing yards, receiving yards, dashing touchdowns, interceptions, sacks, you title it. It doesn’t particularly say an incentive for mixed dashing and receiving yards might be included, but a number of consultants on each the crew and agent sides we consulted mentioned that’s widespread follow. It is also doable incentives might be constructed based mostly on mixed offensive and defensive enjoying time, or for successful each or both Offensive and Defensive Participant of the 12 months.
“What’s fascinating is you may’t normally tie an offensive class to a defensive participant and vice versa, with out it being LTBE,” considered one of our crew cap consultants mentioned. “However in [Hunter’s] case, I assume you may argue he performs each.”
LTBE is brief for “Seemingly To Be Earned,” which is a vital class in contract incentives within the NFL. If an incentive is characterised as “Not Seemingly To Be Earned,” or NLTBE, the crew shouldn’t be required to depend that quantity towards its wage cap (till it’s earned, at which era the quantity will get deducted from the cap the next 12 months). If the motivation is LTBE, the crew should embrace its worth within the participant’s cap quantity. Typically, it is easy to find out which incentives are which. If the participant or crew achieved the feat the prior season, it is LTBE; in the event that they did not, it is NLTBE. That is why we see groups put in incentive bonuses tied to a participant getting, say, eight sacks in a season when he had solely seven the 12 months earlier than. It permits the motivation to be categorized as NLTBE and never counted towards the cap.
The CBA additionally states that as many as eight NLTBE incentive clauses may be included in a contract, and when you go over that quantity, any incentives however the eight with the bottom greenback values connected to them should be counted as LTBE. The CBA doesn’t seem to incorporate a restrict on LTBE incentives, however groups are likely to restrict them as a result of they should depend them towards the cap.
So with all this context, it might be fascinating to see how artistic the Jaguars will or will not let Hunter and his brokers get when attempting to place incentives in his subsequent deal. They might create mixtures that would not make sense for every other participant — stuff like an additional $1 million if he has eight receiving touchdowns and eight interceptions in the identical season. However it might be much more difficult for a participant who has compiled main statistical accomplishments on each side of the ball to get a crew to comply with incentives they should depend as Seemingly To Be Earned.
Hunter doubtlessly initiatives as a singular participant in NFL historical past. Who is aware of … possibly he will not play vital snaps on each side of the ball. However it certain looks as if he desires to, and that the crew that drafted him is open to it. If he does, and if he performs the best way he performed in faculty, we might be trying on the NFL’s model of Shohei Ohtani, the star pitcher/slugger who cashed in on his twin skills with a 10-year, $700 million contract when he signed with the Los Angeles Dodgers in free company two winters in the past.
Main League Baseball has no wage cap, so it is clearly not so simple as including a top-five large receiver wage (at present $32 million or extra per 12 months) to a top-five cornerback wage (at present $21 million or extra per 12 months). However the Jaguars — or whoever finally indicators Hunter as a free agent — might be confronted with the problem of getting to construct a contract, throughout the league’s CBA and wage cap parameters, that pays him as two gamers in a single. Heck, by the point he is up for a brand new contract, the league and the gamers might be negotiating a brand new CBA and making modifications to account for doable future Travis Hunters.
It is all very enjoyable to consider, even when we’re just a few weeks into the Hunter two-way experiment. He may find yourself being a sport changer in additional methods than one.